Attorney advertising. Office in Tampa.

St. Petersburg Tax Lawyer
Menu

IRS Services

Unfiled Returns and the IRS Substitute for Return

If you do not file a required return, the IRS can prepare a substitute for return under section 6020(b). That return usually taxes the income it can see and skips deductions you could have claimed. Filing your own signed return is how you replace it. There is no statute that says the IRS may only ask for six years.

Reviewed by Darrin T. Mish, Attorney ·

The filing obligation is federal. Florida does not have a personal income tax, so a St. Petersburg resident who stopped filing did not create a second state income-tax case. The IRS still receives the W-2s, 1099s, and K-1s. When those forms pile up and no Form 1040 arrives, the IRS can prepare a return for you under section 6020(b). The IRS explains the practical version on Filing past due tax returns. I help people in St. Petersburg and Pinellas County get those years filed before a substitute return hardens into an assessment. The office is in Tampa.

What a substitute return does

The IRS page says a substitute return might not give you credit for deductions and exemptions you are entitled to, and that filing status is often the least favorable one the IRS can use. The tax is usually higher than a real return. Before assessment, the IRS sends a Notice of Deficiency, CP3219N, the 90-day letter. You have 90 days to file the past-due return or to petition the Tax Court. The IRS says you cannot request an extension of that 90 days. If you do neither, it assesses. If you live outside the United States, the deficiency period is 150 days. Do not assume you are in that group because you winter somewhere else. Read the letter.

The IRS assessment statute page says that if you never voluntarily file, the three-year limit on assessment does not start. The IRS can assess a substitute return without that three-year clock. When you later file your own return, the three-year period can begin. Filing is what starts a normal clock. Not filing is what leaves it open.

The six-year practice, stated carefully

You will hear that “the IRS only wants six years.” That comes from Policy Statement 5-133, IRM 1.2.1.6.18, and from IRM 5.1.11. The manual says enforcement is normally pursued for a six-year period, that the taxpayer may still file every open year, and that going shorter or longer requires a manager’s approval. IRM 4.12.1 says the same thing for exams: as a general rule, enforcement should not extend beyond six prior years, and the facts can justify a different period. Trust-fund quarters, fraud, and illegal-source income are the situations where the IRS looks past six years. I will not tell you that six signed returns buy a payment plan if a revenue officer is holding a seventh year of unpaid payroll tax.

The IRS past-due page also says to file every return that is due, whether or not you can pay. A refund must be claimed within three years of the due date, including extensions in the way section 6511 measures it, or you lose it. The IRS will hold a refund when another year is unfiled. Filing only the refund years and hiding the balance-due years is how people lose the refund and still owe the tax.

Penalties and what comes after you file

A late return can bring the failure-to-file penalty under section 6651(a)(1), 5 percent of the unpaid tax per month, up to 25 percent, and the failure-to-pay penalty under section 6651(a)(2), one-half of one percent per month, up to 25 percent. When both run, the failure-to-file rate is reduced by the failure-to-pay rate so the combined monthly rate in those months is 5 percent. Interest is separate and the rate changes quarterly. I am not quoting this quarter’s interest rate. After the returns are in, the collection choice is a payment plan, an offer, or hardship status. Penalty relief, if you qualify, is on the penalty page. First-time abate is not available for a stack of years that all carry penalties. The compliance history has to be clean.

Bankruptcy timing

A return you file today can start the two-year clock in 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(1)(B)(ii). Under the hanging paragraph of 11 U.S.C. § 523(a), a return the IRS prepares under IRC § 6020(b) is not a return for discharge purposes. Do not file five years of returns and a bankruptcy in the same season and expect the tax to disappear. I analyze that timing. I do not file the bankruptcy. See tax dischargeability analysis.

The St. Petersburg page is unfiled returns in St. Petersburg. Call (813) 229-7100 with whatever letters you have, including a CP3219N if the 90 days are running. Office: 15421 N Florida Ave, Tampa, FL 33613. Serving Pinellas County. No St. Petersburg office.

Order wage and income transcripts for the years you did not file before you or a preparer invent the income. Form 4506-T, or the IRS online transcript tool, shows the W-2s and 1099s the IRS already has. A return that omits a form the IRS has will be examined. A return that reports only those forms, and misses income that was never reported to the IRS, creates a different problem if the amount is large. Start with what the IRS can already see, then add the rest from your records.

Questions people ask

Is the “six-year” rule a law?

No. Policy Statement 5-133, in IRM 1.2.1.6.18, and IRM 5.1.11 say enforcement of delinquent returns is normally pursued for six years, and that a shorter or longer period needs managerial approval. The IRS also says you are required to file every delinquent return. Six years is a collection practice, not a statute of limitations on filing.

What is a substitute for return?

Section 6020(b) lets the IRS prepare a return when you do not. The IRS says that return might not give you deductions or credits you could claim, and that it will send a Notice of Deficiency, CP3219N, before it assesses. You generally have 90 days to file your own return or petition the Tax Court.

Can the IRS assess tax forever if I never file?

The IRS assessment-statute page says that if you do not voluntarily file a required return, the IRS can assess at any time under the substitute-for-return program. Once you file a real return, the ordinary three-year assessment period can start.

Does Florida have a state income-tax return I also failed to file?

No. Florida has no personal state income tax. The unfiled return that matters here is the federal one. Information returns such as W-2s and 1099s are still sent to the IRS.

General information, not legal advice. Reading this page does not create an attorney-client relationship. Tax rules and dollar thresholds change; confirm the current figures for your tax year before acting.

Call (813) 229-7100